Letter · May 43 BC · Romae

Ad M. Brutum 1.2

Ad M. Brutum 1.2

Headnote

Cicero to M. Brutus, from Rome, late May 43 BC — Perseus dateline Scr. Romae ex. m. Mai. a. 711 (43). The meta entry assigns this to mid-May (15 May) at month precision; the dateline’s ex.~m.~Mai. (“at the end of May”) would place it a week or two later, but within the same month. The letter is a hurried postscript: Cicero has already written and sealed a previous dispatch when Brutus’s fresh news arrives. Antony has been defeated at Mutina (April), Decimus Brutus has burst out from siege, and the immediate eastern question is what Dolabella — who fled the consulship into Asia after murdering Trebonius in Smyrna — will do next. The astonishing item: Dolabella has sent five cohorts across into the Thracian Chersonese, into the teeth of M. Brutus’s five legions, cavalry, and auxiliaries. Cicero’s tone is incredulous, almost amused (“the bandit has been so far out of his senses”).

Section 2 endorses Brutus’s caution in not leaving Apollonia and Dyrrhachium before the news from Italy made the strategic picture clear, and his subsequent resolve to move east into the Chersonese. Section 3 is the one that makes the letter sting: Brutus has reported a mutiny in the Fourteenth Legion engineered by C. Antonius (Mark Antony’s brother, captured at Apollonia), and Cicero — in the polite preface “you will take this in good part” — tells Brutus bluntly that he approves the soldiers’ severity more than Brutus’s own. The letter then breaks off; the Perseus text marks the lacuna “** *”. The indulgent handling of C. Antonius is the recurring political quarrel that will shape Cicero’s last letters to Brutus over the coming weeks.

The letter was already written and sealed when a dispatch was delivered to me from you, full of fresh news — and most astonishing of all, that Dolabella has sent five cohorts into the Chersonese. Does he have such an abundance of troops that the man who was being reported as in flight out of Asia tries to make a grab at Europe? And what on earth did he suppose he would do with five cohorts, when you in those parts have five legions, first-rate cavalry, and the largest auxiliary forces? Those cohorts I trust are already yours, since the bandit has been so far out of his senses.
scripta et obsignata iam epistula litterae mihi redditae sunt a te plenae rerum novarum, maximeque mirabile Dolabellam quinque cohortis misisse in Chersonesum. adeone copiis abundat ut is qui ex Asia fugere dicebatur Europam appetere conetur? quinque autem cohortibus quidnam se facturum arbitratus est, cum tu †eo† quinque legiones, optimum equitatum, maxima auxilia haberes? quas quidem cohortis spero iam tuas esse, quoniam latro ille tam fuit demens.
I praise your judgement vehemently, that you did not move your army from Apollonia and Dyrrhachium before you had heard of Antony’s flight, the breakout of Brutus, and the victory of the Roman people. And so what you write next — that you have resolved to lead your army into the Chersonese, and not to permit the supremacy of the Roman people to be made a plaything by a criminal so consummate — you do in keeping both with your own dignity and with the commonwealth.
tuum consilium vehementer laudo quod non prius exercitum Apollonia Dyrrhachioque movisti quam de Antoni fuga audisti, Bruti eruptione, populi Romani victoria. itaque quod scribis post ea statuisse te ducere exercitum in Chersonesum nec pati sceleratissimo hosti ludibrio esse imperium populi Romani, facis ex tua dignitate et ex re publica.
As to what you write about the mutiny that took place in the Fourteenth Legion through the treachery of C. Antonius (you will take this in good part), the strictness of the soldiers commends itself to me more than yours does. ** *
quod scribis de seditione quae facta est in legione quarta decima fraude C. Antoni (in bonam partem accipies), magis mihi probatur militum severitas quam tua. ** *

Cite this passage

Ad M. Brutum 1.2

Pick a format and click Copy. The permalink jumps any reader to this exact section.

Support this project

Free to read here. Buy the ebook to support the work.

Kindle