Letter · 53 BC · Romae

Ad Familiares 7.12

Ad Familiares 7.12

Headnote

Cicero to C. Trebatius Testa in Gaul, written from Rome in the early days of February 53 BC. Vibius Pansa, returning from Caesar’s camp, has reported to Cicero that Trebatius has gone over to Epicureanism; Cicero, mock-scandalised, writes at once. The joke is a triple one: at the camp at Samarobriva (Caesar’s winter quarters in Belgic Gaul) for breeding philosophers fit only for seaside Tarentum; at Trebatius, who has apparently picked up his new doctrine from Pansa’s circle; and at the friend “Zeius,” whose name in the manuscripts is corrupt but who was evidently another Epicurean of Cicero’s acquaintance, sufficient to make Trebatius’s earlier orthodoxy already a little suspect.

The second paragraph is sustained legal-philosophical banter. Epicureanism, with its principle that pleasure is the measure of all things and that the wise man should not enter public life, is set against the formulae of the civil law in which Trebatius is a recognised expert: the action on a fiduciary trust, with its standard phrase ut inter bonos bene agier oportet; the action communi dividundo for partitioning common property; and the archaic oath per Iovem lapidem, sworn over a stone with imprecations on perjury — all of them, Cicero says, drained of force on Epicurean premises. The final swipe is at the wretched Latin town of Ulubrae, whose population (later the buzzing frogs of 7.18) will have no civic life left to them if Trebatius adopts the Epicurean lathe biosas. The Greek verb politeuesthai — “to take part in public life” — clinches the point. Cicero closes with a half-serious request for news.

I had been wondering what it was that had made you break off sending me letters; my friend Pansa has now disclosed it — you have turned Epicurean. What a splendid camp! What, I ask you, would you have done if I had packed you off to Tarentum, and not to Samarobriva? I had my doubts about you even back then, when you were maintaining the same opinions as my friend Zeius.
mirabar quid esset, quod tu mihi litteras mittere intermisisses: indicavit mihi Pansa meus Epicureum te esse factum. O castra praeclara! quid tu fecisses, si te Tarentum et non Samarobrivam misissem? iam tum mihi non placebas, cum idem tuebare quod †Zeius, familiaris meus.
But how, I should like to know, will you uphold the civil law, when you do everything for your own sake, and nothing for the citizens’? Where, again, will that formula of the action on a fiduciary trust come in — “as it ought to be done well between honest men”? For who is the honest man, if a man does nothing except for his own sake? What rule will you lay down in the action for partitioning common property, when nothing can be “common” among men who measure everything by their own pleasure? And how will it suit you to swear by “Jupiter of the Stone,” when you know that Jupiter can be angry with no one? What will become, furthermore, of the people of Ulubrae, if you have decided that one ought not to take part in public life? politeuesthai So if you are quite simply defecting from us, I take it ill; but if it is merely convenient to humour Pansa, I forgive you. Only do write to me at some point about what you are up to and what you want done for you, or attended to, at this end.
sed quonam modo ius civile defendes, cum omnia tua causa facias, non civium? Ubi porro illa erit formula fiduciae: ’VT INTER BONOS BENE AGIER OPORTET? †quis enim est, qui facit nihil nisi sua causa? quod ius statues ’COMMVNI DIVIDVNDO,’ quom commune nihil possit esse apud eos, qui omnia voluptate sua metiuntur? quo modo autem tibi placebit ’IOVEM LAPIDEM IVRARE,’ cum scias Iovem iratum esse nemini posse? quid fiet porro populo Ulubrano, si tu statueris politeu/esqai non oportere? qua re si plane a nobis deficis, moleste fero, sin Pansae adsentari commodumst, ignosco; modo scribe aliquando ad nos quid agas et a nobis quid fieri aut curari velis.

Cite this passage

Ad Familiares 7.12

Pick a format and click Copy. The permalink jumps any reader to this exact section.

Support this project

Free to read here. Buy the ebook to support the work.

Kindle